Miss South Carolina Teen Legacy
Miss Lower State Carolina Teen
Kathryn Lynn Stoudenmire, 2001
Miss Columbia Teen
Danielle Wilson, 2002
Miss Florence Teen
Shelley Bryson Benthall, 2003
Miss Columbia Teen
Brooke Lauren Rauscher, 2004
Miss Upstate Teen
Lindley Mayer, 2005
Top 15 Miss America's Outstanding Teen
Miss Lexington Teen
Maggie Hill, 2006
Top 10 Miss America's Outstanding Teen, Preliminary Talent Miss America's Outstanding Teen
Miss Greenville Teen
Lauren Lytle, 2007
Miss Powdersville Teen
Courtney Cisson, 2008
Succeeded Taylor Hanna Fitch
Miss Upstate Teen
Taylor Hanna Fitch, 2008
Miss America's Outstanding Teen Winner
Miss Laurens County Teen
Ali Rogers, 2009
Top 10 Miss America's Outstanding Teen
Miss Myrtle Beach Teen
Caroline Blanton, 2010
Miss Columbia Teen
Caitlen Patton, 2011
Miss Greater Greer Teen
Sydney Sill, 2012
Miss Greater Mauldin Teen
Rachel Wyatt, 2012
Miss America's Outstanding Teen Winner
Miss Mauldin Teen
Brook Sill, 2013
Miss Greater Easley Teen
Hope Harvard, 2014
Miss Hilton Head Island Teen
Sarah Hamrick, 2015
Miss Clemson Teen
Makayla Stark, 2016
Miss Woodmont High School Teen
Ally McCaslin, 2017
Miss River City Teen
Berkley Bryant, 2018
Miss Columbia Teen
Kellan Fenegan, 2019 & 2020
Miss Capital City Teen
Dabria Aguilar, 2021
